The 26 best mascaras of all time, according to Allure Editors

When your workplace is Allure, everyone and their grandmother treat you like an encyclopedia of living, breathing beauty – no condescension, but the honest truth. Not a day goes by when at least one person casually asks us, “What’s your favorite [insert beauty product here]?” The best mascara is undoubtedly one of the most talked about topics. Everyone wants to know what makes our lashes look false without the flaking, flaking and stringing issues.

While some of us indulge in treatments like lash extensions or lash lifting, we all have our own proven mascaras that replenish on a regular basis. Some of our picks might be curly mascaras for a fuller, lifted look, while other editors at Allure prefer one of the best waterproof mascaras for a smudge-free finish. Whatever result you’re trying to achieve, we probably know exactly which mascara you need.

With that in mind, we’ve rounded up all-time favorite mascaras from our editors, including a few Best of Beauty winners, with brands ranging from drugstore favorites like Maybelline New York to Sephora favorites like Too Faced and Anastasia Beverly Hills. We also have a luxury market (hello, Dior and YSL Beauty).

Discover the best and boldest mascaras that give Allure editors more volume, curl and length every day.

Revolution Beauty Makeup Revolution 5D Lash Pow mascara

Buy Revolution Beauty Makeup Revolution 5D Lash Pow Mascara for just $ 10. In just a few swipes, this Best of Beauty 2022 winner gives the look of false lashes and adds volume, thickness and length to each lash.

Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara

Two-time winner of the Allure Readers’ Choice Award, Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara conditions lashes with a volumizing, thickening and jet black formula. This flicker-inducing mascara has a double-sided wand that applies product evenly and removes lumps for perfectly defined lashes.

MAC Magic Extension 5mm Fiber Mascara

Skyscraper length, amazing thickness and black tint – MAC’s Magic Extension 5mm Fiber mascara does it all. It’s so cool that all of our employees have given it the One to Watch seal of approval. Publisher Talia Gutierrez previously stated that this mascara is so impressive that she skipped the lash appointment.

“As a beauty assistant here at Allure, I test makeup (insert smiling emoji) all day, but so far no mascara has come close to the volume and length I get with lash extensions,” she said. .

High Water Volumizing Tubing Mascara

Caliray’s Come Hell of High Water Volumizing Tubing Mascara is formulated with nourishing argan oil and tube technology that is water resistant but applies instantly at the end of the day. Not to mention that it also contains film-forming agents, which make lashes look extra long and voluminous, which is why it won the Best of Beauty 2022 award.

Mascara Nars Climax

The bold name of this mascara alone is intriguing enough to grab our attention, but Nars’ Climax mascara is also tempted to pass thanks to its buildable and flexible formula. Business writer Jennifer Hussein claims this is one of her favorite eyelash enhancing mascaras that she describes as “thin, thin and thin”.

The thing is, I have very sensitive eyes, so false lashes are a big no to me. One of the few mascaras that can tolerate my watery eyes is this light formula. I just need a hand to get a natural look. , to achieve a puffy appearance. For a more dramatic look, two coats do the job without fail of getting wisps and chunks between my lashes. ”

Essence Lash Princess Mascara with false eyelash effect

This $ 5 mascara has earned TikTok fame for its low price and high quality. Essence’s Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara has gone viral for its amazing volumizing effects on upper and lower lashes. The brand has made numerous spin-off mascaras, but Hussein says you can’t beat the original. “It costs less than a latte and outperforms many of its luxury competitors, so what’s not to love?” he says.

Better than the Sekvolume mascara

The public spoke: the face is even better than the mascara gender volume has an iconic formula as the real name. This winner of the readers selection price has a tortuous block that embraces each eyelash, thickens vigorously and expands every process.

“A cleaning gives your eyelashes a nice black rain – a little more than those I call” natural “eyelashes,” says an attractive assistant. “Now, continue to sweep and become really soft and spacious eyelashes. You can probably ventilate the wind with someone with some eye bulbs, so powerful I speak.”

Beauty attacks rare perfect universal volumizing mascara

If there is a brand that is truly the case with beauty brands of celebrity, it is the cosmetic line of Selena Gomez, a rare beauty. Exhibition in: Mascara of the universal volume of complete shock, air conditioning, formula infused with castor oil, which is so good, won the allure readers’ Choice in 2022 award. Sarah Han, a shopkeeper Sarah Han, says a disordered application and an innovative brush head.

“The candidacy process is seamlessly from the beginning to the end and to the blocking of the brush often for each eyelash”, she wrote first by charm.

Clean volume of Covergl Lash Blast

Covergirl Lash Blast The eyelashes are iconic for their rights. Volume Formula is a three -stroke winner of the Best of Beauty Award, but now the family extraction family is expanding with the volume Clean Clean Cevergirl Lash Blast, the first vegan formula of the pharmacy brand. “It is very built and gives me long and fluttering eyelashes of zero,” says an attractive former employee. “My eyes are very sensitive and the sulphate formula without parabens does not irritate at all.” It does not hurt that the formula also contains Argan and Marula oils.

L’Oréal Paris Bambi waterproof

Take your eyes to Twiggy fans like to clean this extended mascara, an Kara McGrath daily digital journalist. “One of the most interesting things of L’Oréal a Paris Bambi waterproof is the so called.” Wide eyes brush.  McGrath also says that this 2020 Best of Beauty Award winning mascara is perfect in the days, when you want your performance to be as natural as possible, and she also indicates that “not” is a lump “when applied.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Lash Brag Mascara

The news journalist Nicola Dall’Snene says that this best winner of the beauty of 2020 is simply “different”. The slightly thicker formula and the curved and dense brush create a more often and wider appearance. But this does not mean that you cannot use this mascara in minimal times for the eyes, because from the ASE swears with this choice to create thick, spacious and spacious eyelashes or somewhere “.

Eleven. Large mood mascara cosmetics

We love the winning formula, especially if he is less than $ 10. McGrath says that this is the favorite of her pharmacy for her impressive curl. “When I tested the formula for the first time, I applied for the first to 10 in the morning.